Local vets disappointed in Supreme Court's Stolen Valor decision

Reported by: Ryan Smith
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 7/04/2012 6:50 pm
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. -- The United States Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling that allows anyone to claim they have earned combat medals, regardless if it’s true or not.

Sifting through family history is a point of pride for Aaron Bennett. Serving under the stars and stripes runs deep in his family. The men in his family fought in every war since the American Revolution. Some died in battle and all fought for freedom.

“They've signed a blank check to the United States of America up to and including their lives,” said Bennett.

Sadly, there are people who don't make that sacrifice and still gain the glory. The list includes Charles White, of St. Augustine. The former Marine claimed he earned four Purple Hearts but was later prosecuted in federal court under the Stolen Valor Act.

“It's a slap in the face to me, my wife, my father and anybody else who has served,” said Bennett.

Even after service, Bennett is on a mission to out the fakers, forgers and posers who make up the military’s Hall of Shame.

“If they have a Facebook, we all dog pile their Facebook site and we just continuously hound them and hound them until they do finally come public and apologize.”

But the impersonators recently scored a major victory at the U.S. Supreme Court when Justices struck down the Stolen Valor Act in a 6-3 vote. The law made it a federal crime to lie about receiving military medals. The majority opinion ruled that the broadly written law violated the First Amendment right to free speech. The decision was disappointing for this dad. "How am I supposed to teach her the right thing to do if our own federal government says yes, to go out and lie to people and say you've done all those great, honorable things that you never did.”

There are plans for a more specific law in the works in Congress that would prohibit falsifying claims of military service. Some proponents are pushing to create a public database of honor recipients, which would allow people to verify suspicious claims.
Share
4 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of Action News Jacksonville

therev - 7/5/2012 6:33 PM
0 Votes
I believe that the Supreme Court made a big mistake. We all have had family or friends that have lost their lives or made other sacrifices for our freedom. I do not believe that a person should ever be allowed to lie about the medals he received. As for sweetsuebjax. You husband made a great sacrifice to give you and your daughter the freedom we enjoy. You should be able to get part of his disability if they still have it for the vets. I am sorry I never served. My hearing kept me out. So stop feeling sorry for what happened and look to the future, and the freedoms that your husband and millions like him have given us over the years, and will continue to in the future. Your little girl will live in a free country to grow and mature in. All of this because we fought for our freedom

SweetSuziBJax - 7/5/2012 6:00 PM
1 Vote
I am a single mother of a wonderful 4 year old little girl whose father was twice awarded the purple heart for wounds received in combat. It is because of those wounds that he is not capable of parenting our child. It may seem to many that this Supreme Court decision is a disappointment, but in my opinion it was a victory. My daughter's father made the sacrifices he did to protect basic rights such as freedom of speech. The Supreme Court holding up the right to speak freely just shows that what these veterans and their families have sacrificed for is worth it and is real.

whosaysnocan - 7/5/2012 2:43 PM
0 Votes
Also forgot to mention that all veterans have a DD-214 that lists their awards. If someone boasts about their service they should be able/required to provide their DD-214.

whosaysnocan - 7/5/2012 7:17 AM
0 Votes
My husband & I are veterans as well as many in our family. Some are still deployed to the Middle East doing what they are trained to do. My husband still has his draft card, that he shows to past & present all volunteer service people. He did not have a choice but to serve. The Supreme Court's decision to allow some to pretend to be decorated combat veterans is part of what we served to protect. This said, the best we can do is to identify these losers and "try" to embarrass them. I say "try" as anyone that would "steal" valor is less than a decent American. I praise those that have and are serving in our military. Thank you! God Bless America!
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.