• Four-day manhunt over after suspect in deadly hit-and-run surrenders

    By: Lorena Inclan , Action News Jax


    ST. JOHNS COUNTY, Fla. - The search for 37-year-old Henry Haigler III is now over.

    MORE: SJSO: Suspected driver in fatal hit-and-run on Race Track Road turns himself in

    But the investigation is only just beginning.

    He’s now being held on a $50,000 bond at the St. Johns County jail.


    Sheriff’s Office spokesman Chuck Mulligan said Haigler reached out to a Sheriff's Office detective this morning.

    “[He] stated that he had a desire to turn himself in. He had already selected a predetermined location, which was a sidewalk in downtown St. Augustine,” said Mulligan.

    The arrest comes five days after deputies say he hit two female cyclists on Race Track Road and kept going. 

    His car was eventually found in his garage and a warrant put out for his arrest.

    “It’s really difficult with hit-and-runs to even catch a suspect, to even have a description of a car. What made the difference in this case?” asked Action News Jax reporter Lorena Inclán.

    “I would say there were several things. One, the eyewitness accounts,” replied Mulligan.

    Surveillance cameras also played a significant role in helping deputies put together a crucial timeline.

    STAY UPDATED: Download the Action News Jax app for live updates on breaking stories

    Download WJAX Apps

    “From that, we can almost create a bread trail from the scene to the house,” said Mulligan.

    We talked to the son of one of the women by phone Wednesday.

    He tells Action News Jax the suspect lives in his mother’s neighborhood. The victim’s son doesn’t want him to bond out of jail and return to his home.

    Haigler has hired an attorney. 

    Next Up: