Woman receives sentence for luring Middleburg teen Kolton Shearer to his death

Woman Sentenced for Luring Teenager to his Death

CLAY COUNTY, Fla. — Alexandra Schreffler received a sentence of 15 years in prison Monday morning in Clay County, for her involvement in the robbery and murder of a Middleburg teenager.

In 2016, Schreffler told police three men allegedly told her to find someone they could rob.

She later told police she targeted high school baseball player, Kolton Shearer, 18, on Facebook because he was "an easy target."

Content Continues Below

Authorities said she led Shearer to a Green Cove Springs home to be robbed, where he was shot and killed.

Four people, including Schreffler were arrested.

Only Action News Jax's Bridgette Matter was in the courtroom as Shearer's mother gave an emotional statement three years after losing her son.

"I hold you the most responsible for Kolton's death. Had it not been for your senseless actions of luring him there that night, there's no doubt in my mind that he would still be here with us today," Shearer's mother said.
"You knew when sending him that message that you would be putting him in a terrible situation. He trusted you, he thought of you as a friend and you took advantage of that. My heart is forever broken, I will never be the same person I was before I lost Kolton. My whole life has been ruined."

Schreffler entered a plea deal in 2016 for reduced charges of armed robbery, on the condition that she would be available to testify against the three other suspects if the case went to trial.

Another suspect, Jordan Coleman, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and was sentenced to 25 years in Florida state prison in July 2018.

Taurean Johnson and Ozell McNabb Jr., who were accused of robbing and killing Shearer, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in February.

They were sentenced to more than 25 years in prison.


Download WJAX Apps