Clay County

Clay County police looking for victims of local man accused of multistate pigeon drop scam

Clay County Sheriff's Office is warning the community of a scam for missing jury duty.

ORANGE PARK, Fla. — Clay County Sheriff’s Office is looking for victims of a Florida “pigeon drop” scammer by the name of William Coleman.


According to CCSO, Coleman, 50, was arrested for his connection with two “pigeon drop” scam investigations in Maryland. Coleman is from Orange Park and was arrested by the Orange County Sheriff’s Office in Orlando on Tuesday.

A pigeon drop scam involves convincing a victim to give the suspect a large amount of cash as collateral with the hope of sharing a larger sum of money. There have been nine pigeon drop scams reported in Clay County in 2023.

[DOWNLOAD: Free Action News Jax app for alerts as news breaks]

Coleman is charged in connection with two cases. In one case, he and his accomplice or accomplices successfully stole thousands of dollars from their victim. In the second case, the victim did not lose any money. In both incidents, the victims were women and senior citizens.

The successful scam occurred on June 8, in the 6300 block of Marlboro Pike in District Heights. The attempted theft occurred on June 1, 2023, in the 12000 block of Central Avenue in Mitchellville.

Following an extensive investigation, Prince George Police Department detectives identified Coleman as a suspect.

At the time of his arrest on Tuesday and through subsequent search warrants, PGPD Financial Crimes detectives recovered multiple pieces of evidence, including more than $100,000 in counterfeit cash at his Florida home. CCSO assisted with the search of his home in Orange Park.

Read: Taylor Swift attends Jets-Chiefs game

Pigeon drop scammers often carry notes or fake letters from non-existent law firms confirming the receipt of a large amount of money from either a settlement or inheritance. A letter of this nature was recovered inside of Coleman’s car.

A newspaper wrapped in a bandana was also recovered. In many pigeon drop scams, scammers use bandanas to wrap the money a victim withdraws from his or her bank. Scammers then swap out the money for bundled newspapers unbeknownst to the victims.

Read: Detours in place as FDOT enters Phase III of King Street drainage project

“These crimes target some of the most vulnerable in our community. I want residents in Prince George’s County to know our detectives work relentlessly to identify and arrest suspects in these scams. Regarding Coleman, we do not believe he acted alone and that he worked with accomplices. Detectives are looking into whether he is linked to similar crimes along the East Coast. We sincerely thank our law enforcement partners in Florida for assisting us with this significant arrest,” said Chief Malik Aziz, Prince George’s County Police Department.

“I commend the coordinated efforts of Financial Crimes Investigators from the Clay County Sheriff’s Office and Investigators from the Prince George’s County Police Department. The team worked seamlessly to execute a warrant, demonstrating exceptional teamwork. Such crimes occur all too frequently and are predatory in nature, making this arrest a significant success. Thanks to the arrest, law enforcement has prevented further losses to potential victims and put another scammer behind bars. Through the collective efforts of law enforcement, we have effectively put an end to this scammer’s ability to target innocent people, whether in Clay County or elsewhere,” said Sheriff Michelle Cook, Clay County Sheriff’s Office.

Read: Federal student loan payments resume after pause due to pandemic

Coleman remains in custody in Florida pending extradition to Prince George’s County.

The PGPD wants to remind residents to never give money or financial information to anyone whom they just met in person, online or on the phone. If something seems too good to be true, it usually is.

Read: Kirsten Bridegan delivers Bexley Box to Palatka Police Department

Anyone with information on this suspect or who could be a potential victim and would like to speak to a PGPD Financial Crimes Unit detective may call 301-516-1464.

Anyone with information who wants to contact Crime Solvers may call 1-866-411-TIPS (8477) or go online at, or use the “P3 Tips” mobile app (search “P3 Tips” in the Apple Store or Google Play to download the app onto your mobile device.) You can remain anonymous.

More information about the cases can be found HERE.

[SIGN UP: Action News Jax Daily Headlines Newsletter]

Click here to download the free Action News Jax news and weather apps, click here to download the Action News Jax Now app for your smart TV and click here to stream Action News Jax live.

Comments on this article