Florida insurance market dodges bullet with Hurricane Idalia

JACKSONVILLE, Fla — Florida leaders had been crossing their fingers in hopes Mother Nature would spare the state from a major hurricane this year, as the state’s property is in the early stages of recovery after facing total collapse last year.

Thankfully, it seems like Hurricane Idalia won’t be the death blow to the market many had feared.

>>> STREAM ACTION NEWS JAX LIVE <<<

Hurricane Idalia’s impact came at a tragic cost to communities in the storm’s path, but in some sense, Florida insurers dodged a bullet.

“Had the storm hit the Tampa, St. Petersburg area we’d be looking at a totally different situation,” said Michael Barry with the Insurance Information Insitute.

[DOWNLOAD: Free Action News Jax app for alerts as news breaks]

Barry said because the storm hit relatively low-population areas, estimated costs to insurers were significantly less than other recent storms, with early insured damage estimates putting the cost around $9 billion.

“When you compare it for instance to Hurricane Ian, which was in excess of $50 billion and was the second costliest natural disaster in US history, Idalia is about one-fifth the size of Ian as an insurance event,” said Barry.

Jeff Brandes with the Florida Policy Project worked for years on the property insurance crisis as a state senator.

[SIGN UP: Action News Jax Daily Headlines Newsletter]

“I would say that the patient is in stable but improving condition,” said Brandes.

Brandes argued reforms passed by lawmakers in a round of special sessions last year aimed at reducing litigation costs in the property insurance market helped position the industry to weather a storm like Idalia.

“Ultimately, I think it really is going to take some time and lack of storms in major populated areas that are going to kind of provide the medicine that we need to cure the property insurance market,” said Brandes.

Brandes predicted homeowners in less impacted areas like here in Duval likely won’t see their rates increase because of Idalia, but he warned there are still three months left to go in hurricane season and another major storm could change that calculation.

Click here to download the free Action News Jax news and weather apps, click here to download the Action News Jax Now app for your smart TV and click here to stream Action News Jax live.